State Aid Law Blog

State Aid Uncovered Blog

In Lexxion’s State Aid Uncovered blog, Prof. Phedon Nicolaides publishes weekly critical analyses of recent State aid judgments and decisions. Each post presents the key points of a court judgment or EU Commission decision, places it in the context of similar case law or practice, assesses the underlying reasoning and highlights any inconsistencies or contradictions.

Guest contributions from other State aid experts will also be published on the blog at irregular intervals to complement the content of the blog posts.

Subscribe now!

18. June 2019  |   State Aid Uncovered by Phedon Nicolaides

Is it OK to Tax Company Size?*
State Aid Blogs -
Progressive tax rates that are consistent with the objective of the tax system are not necessarily selective. Introduction Member States are free to design their corporate tax systems as long as they do not grant State aid or infringe fundamental internal market freedoms. A question that arises in discussions on what Member States may or may not do when designing […]
read more
2 Comments
11. June 2019  |   State Aid Uncovered by Phedon Nicolaides

I) Unlimited State Guarantees II) Effect on Trade
State Aid Blogs - StateAidHub blogpost23
A competitor who wants to challenge a Commission decision authorising State aid without a formal investigation must, first, show that it is seriously harmed by the aid. Introduction This week’s article reviews two judgments: one on unlimited state guarantees granted by France [case T-135/17, Scor v European Commission][1] and another on aid that was found not to affect trade between Member […]
read more
No Comments
4. June 2019  |   State Aid Uncovered by Phedon Nicolaides

Not Every Compensation Is a Compensation in the Meaning of Altmark
State Aid Blogs - StateAidHub blogpost22 electricity Altmark SGEI
Regulation and licensing do not constitute obligations for the provision of an SGEI. Compensation for changes in public policy is not compensation that complies with the Altmark conditions. Introduction The calculation of the compensation for the net extra costs of public service obligations [PSO] is a difficult task. On 15 May 2019, in case C-706/17, Achema et al v Lithuania […]
read more
1 Comment
28. May 2019  |   State Aid Uncovered by Phedon Nicolaides

What Happens when Internal Market Rules and State Aid Rules Clash?
State Aid Blogs - StateAidHub blogpost21 Tax Refund
A tax refund may not be granted, if it constitutes non-notified State aid.   Introduction   It is a well-established principle that restrictions on internal market rights or freedoms may not be attached to a State aid measure. Indeed, current State aid rules [e.g. GBER, guidelines] explicitly exclude from their scope any aid measure which is inseparably linked to a […]
read more
No Comments
21. May 2019  |   State Aid Uncovered by Phedon Nicolaides

There Is No Threshold below which Economic Activities Can Be Considered to be Non-economic
State Aid Blogs - StateaidHub blogpost20 Lexxion Port Economic Activities
Non-economic activities have to be accounted separately from economic activities. The exercise of public tasks assigned by the state cannot protect an undertaking from State aid rules. State aid distorts competition even when it aims to remedy distortions. Introduction Ports, like other transport infrastructures, may operate under public obligations some of which may be of economic and some of non-economic […]
read more
2 Comments
16. May 2019  |   State Aid Uncovered by Phedon Nicolaides

Competitors’ Rights
State Aid Blogs - StateaidHub blogpost19 Lexxion Lufthansa Airport StateAid Ryanair Frankfurt Competition EU Commission
A competitor must show that it is substantially affected by State aid approved by the Commission in order to challenge the Commission’s decision. Merely being affected by the aid is not enough. To show that aid has a substantial impact, it is first necessary to define the relevant market. This is different from the “distortion of competition” in the meaning […]
read more
No Comments
7. May 2019  |   State Aid Uncovered by Phedon Nicolaides

Land Development: The Case of Jaguar Land Rover Slovakia
State Aid Blogs - StateAidHub blogpost18 Landrover Jaguar Nitra Stateaid Infrastrsucture Transport Lexxion
Public funding of infrastructure which is not constructed for the specific needs of a company is not State aid.   Introduction An article carried by the Financial Times on 1 May 2019 revealed that Jaguar Land Rover [JLR] decided to make again the iconic Land Rover Defender. The production of this legendary off-roader ended about 10 years ago because it […]
read more
No Comments
30. April 2019  |   State Aid Uncovered by Phedon Nicolaides

The Commission Must Explain its Decision
State Aid Blogs - StateAid Blogpost17 2019 Lexxion UPS DeutschePost Eu Commission State Aid
A Commission decision that affects the legal position of an undertaking is actionable before EU courts. The opening of the formal investigation procedure must lead the Member State concerned to suspend the aid measure and may result in a recovery ruling by a national court. The Commission must be consistent in its reasoning. If it cannot use certain information at […]
read more
No Comments
23. April 2019  |   State Aid Uncovered by Phedon Nicolaides

State Control: The Case of EEG 2012
State Aid Blogs - 5 most read articles 2019
There is crucial difference between control by the state over resources and attribution to the state of the aid granting decision.   Introduction According to the latest edition of the State aid Scoreboard, in 2017 Member States granted a total of EUR 105 billion of State aid to manufacturing and services. Of that amount, 58% or EUR 61 billion supported […]
read more
No Comments
16. April 2019  |   State Aid Uncovered by Phedon Nicolaides

Spanish Football Clubs Score against the Commission: a) Linked Advantages and Disadvantages Must be Assessed Together b) In Determining the Existence of an Advantage, the Commission Must Explain both what it Takes into Account and what it Ignores
State Aid Blogs - StateAidHub blogpost15 Soccer loans Lexxion Spain EU Commission
State measures which are linked and produce both positive and negative effects, must be considered together to determine whether they confer a net advantage to undertakings. Counter-guarantees must be taken into account to determine the existence of advantage even if they are provisional.   Introduction Member States have in a number of cases tried to defend tax reductions or tax […]
read more
No Comments
« Previous PageNext Page »

9. November 2018  |   State Aid Uncovered by Phedon Nicolaides

Using the Correct Methodology to Calculate Public Service Compensation
State Aid Blogs - stellrweb djb1whucfBY unsplash
Compensation for the extra costs of a public service obligation may include a reasonable profit that reflects the risk borne by the provider of the public service.   Introduction   The calculation of the amount of compensation for the extra costs of public service obligations can be difficult and tricky. In the absence of such calculation, aid to providers of […]
read more
No Comments
6. November 2018  |   State Aid Uncovered by Phedon Nicolaides

Unconditional and Unlimited Guarantees and their (In)Compatibility with the Internal Market
State Aid Blogs -
Operating aid is not normally compatible with the internal market. Therefore, State aid provided through state guarantees should not cover operating costs. State aid embedded in guarantees must be quantifiable so that its necessity and proportionality can be assessed. The assessment of State aid must be made within an EU context taking into account its impact on trade.   Introduction […]
read more
No Comments
30. October 2018  |   State Aid Uncovered by Phedon Nicolaides

Tax Inseparably Linked to State Aid
State Aid Blogs - Stateaid Blog43 Tax movie rent
Taxes which are inseparably linked with an aid measure are assessed together with the aid itself.  An increase of the budget of an aid scheme by more than 20% constitutes a change of existing aid that must be notified to the Commission for prior authorisation.   Introduction Taxpayers may not refuse to pay taxes on the grounds that the tax […]
read more
No Comments
23. October 2018  |   State Aid Uncovered by Phedon Nicolaides

Public Service Obligations Must be Properly Defined and Selectivity Must be Proven [1]
State Aid Blogs - Stateaid blog42 Broadcasting
Neither the existence of market failure, nor national laws that designate a service to be in the general interest can replace an official act that assigns to one or more undertakings clearly defined public service obligations.   Introduction The proper definition of public service obligations (PSOs) is an issue that arises with surprising regularity. It is surprising because numerous court […]
read more
No Comments
16. October 2018  |   State Aid Uncovered by Phedon Nicolaides

Unlimited State Guarantees
State Aid Blogs - m 2 1
Unlimited state guarantees create a presumption that the recipient of the guarantee obtains an advantage in the form of cheaper credit. Any advantage in the form of lower risk in transactions with suppliers or clients has to be proven.   Introduction State guarantees must be limited in time and amount and may cover only a specified event. Unlimited and general […]
read more
No Comments
9. October 2018  |   State Aid Uncovered by Phedon Nicolaides

Ex ante Assessment of Future Profitability is Absolutely Necessary
State Aid Blogs - m 1 1
A private investor assesses the prospects of future profitability before it invests. The burden of proof lies with the Member State that claims it has acted as a private investor.   Introduction The market economy investor principle is based on a simple premise: before you commit your money you need to check how much you are likely to get back. […]
read more
No Comments
2. October 2018  |   State Aid Uncovered by Phedon Nicolaides

The Compatibility of State Aid with the Internal Market: Lessons from “Hinkley Point C” – Part III
The objective of common interest that should be supported by State aid does not have to be an objective agreed by all Member States.   Environmental protection Austria argued that the Commission had ignored the potential negative effects of the aid on the environment such as the storing of nuclear waste. The reply of the Court was that “(516) in […]
read more
No Comments
25. September 2018  |   State Aid Uncovered by Phedon Nicolaides

The Compatibility of State Aid with the Internal Market: Lessons from “Hinkley Point C” – Part II
State Aid Blogs - SAH blogpost37 Hinkley Point C UK 2017
The objective of common interest that should be supported by state aid does not have to be an objective agreed by all Member States.   Existence of market failure and need for aid Austria and Luxembourg claimed that the intervention by the UK was not necessary and that there was no evidence that the liberalised market for the generation and […]
read more
No Comments
18. September 2018  |   State Aid Uncovered by Phedon Nicolaides

The Compatibility of State Aid with the Internal Market: Lessons from “Hinkley Point C” – Part I
State Aid Blogs - SAH blogpost37 Hinkley Point C UK 2017
The objective of common interest that should be supported by state aid does not have to be an objective agreed by all Member States.   Introduction On 12 July 2018, the General Court ruled in a complex case brought by Austria and Luxembourg against Commission decision 2015/658 which had authorised State aid for Hinkley Point C, a new nuclear power […]
read more
No Comments
11. September 2018  |   State Aid Uncovered by Phedon Nicolaides

Selectivity Can Exist at Different Levels: The Case of the Spanish Tax Lease System
transport ship
A tax measure may be selective in relation to both intermediate and final beneficiaries.  An undertaking may enjoy a selective advantage even if it passes all tax benefits to other parties.   Introduction A measure that is not selective at one level may be selective at another level and a measure that is selective at one level can also be […]
read more
4 Comments
« Previous PageNext Page »

Subscribe to our newsletter for updates on legal developments, upcoming conferences, workshops, and publications in your areas of interest.

Newsletter: Subscribe now